Indestructible water molecules?

When you’re chaperoning a school trip, you notice things.  Annoying things.  Shown below is a sign at Philadelphia’s Fairmount Water Works Interpretive Center that makes the claim that all the water molecules on Earth are never, ever destroyed — they are immortal entities. If you teach biology, you’ll be instantly outraged, especially when you think of the hundreds of thousands (millions?) of kids who’ve absorbed the contents of this signage as fact.  Details below the image, but see if you can figure out the flaw before you jump.

photosynthesis, water, split, molecule, science, biology, signage, error

The sign is wrong partly because of photosynthesis, which usually involves the splitting of water molecules (to generated electrons).  That little trick evolved about 3,500,000,000 years ago, so I’d wager that most if not all the water originally present on the planet has been replaced by new molecules produced from combustion (including respiration). That’s just a guess, though…I couldn’t find a calculation on the internet.  Download this photograph and use in your lectures to introduce the ideas of photosynthesis and respiration.  If you lecture on science center signage, you can use this to highlight the value of getting a few scientists to proof the graphics.  Or a few 7th graders.

1 thought on “Indestructible water molecules?

  1. Alan Levi

    There’s also the problem that the sign shows a cycle. Time goes forward and is presumably not cyclic (let’s not think Dr. Who for the moment). The sign seems to imply the the little girl drinks a water molecule that is later drunk by a dinosour. Genetics and bio-engineering are not there yet, so this pure speculation.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.