The book, Clear and Concise Communications for Scientists and Engineers, has been recalled by CRC Press due to plagiarism (of me). Or at least they said it was going to be recalled: it is still available for purchase at CRC Press a week after their lawyer gave me the news. But CRC Press / Francis & Taylor / Informa is a massive corporation, so perhaps these things take time.
Anyway, it was nice of CRC to so quickly acknowledge and act on the plagiarism rather than accuse me of plagiarizing them. They also said they would be happy to give refunds to anyone who had already purchased the book.
My only complaint is that they refused to make a public statement about the recall and the reason. In my informal research (previous post), most publishers involved in plagiarism cases do tend to make some sort of statement … even if they initially don’t want to. If CRC wanted to better promote its anti-plagiarism policy to potential authors, making press statements about recalled books would be a wise idea.
Publishers should also get in the habit of running every book through plagiarism-detection software: the sections copy/pasted from my site (Designing conference posters) would have been flagged instantly. But what publisher these days isn’t doing this? Taylor & Francis certainly does it. So the question I have is, why did CRC Press/editor not contact me when those pages were flagged?
By the way, there were a lot of sentences about plagiarism in the book. None of these sentences was plagiarized from my page on plagiarism. Now that would be hilarious.
Just because I was curious … here’s how various publishers have dealt with books that contained plagiarism. Of course, publishers don’t always make public statements about such things, so if you have additions or corrections, please let me know. Similarly, it’s hard to figure out whether the source authors took the plagiarizer (and/or publisher) to court. I know I have 19 in the list … am sort of reserving #20.
Roots (Alex Haley 1976). Doubleday & Company was publisher. Amazon still sells this book. Haley was taken to court by author of The African, which Haley mined for characters, plot, quotes, etc. [details]
The Fitzgeralds and the Kennedys (Doris Kearns Goodwin 1987). I gather she settled with one of her “sources” (Lynne McTaggart) before the plagiarism news was released. Goodwin requested that all copies be destroyed. [details]
Alexander Graham Bell: A Life (James Mackay 1989). He apparently paid the John Wiley & Sons to have the book recalled … as part of deal to avoid being sued by Robert V. Bruce. Mackay was caught plagiarizing his next book, by the way. [details]
The Survivor Personality (Patsy Westcott 1995). Bloomsbury Publishers recalled all the books and had them destroyed. Amazon sells used copies of this book. [details]
When Love Calls (Gail A. McFarland 1999). BET Publications recalled the book. You can still buy used copies on Amazon. Gina Wilkins, who was the author plagiarized, won an out-of-court settlement. [details]
The Wild Blue (Stephen Ambrose 2001). Simon & Schuster publishes paperback with plagiarism removed. [details]
Captain Henry Wirz and Andersonville Prison: A Reappraisal (R. Fred Ruhlman 2006). University of Tennessee Press recalled the book. [details]
How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild and Got a Life (Kaavya Viswanathan 2006). Little, Brown and Company recalled book, cancelled book deal with author. [details]
Shadow Bear (Cassie Edwards 2008). Signet said it found no evidence of plagiarism, then claimed the plagiarism was “fair use”, then decided to part ways with Edwards. [details]
Free (Chris Anderson 2009). Hyperion didn’t pull version with plagiarized passages, but did promise to correct future editions. [details]
Axolotl Roadkill (Helene Hegemann 2010). Ullstein bought rights from plagiarized author, then republished book. [details]
How We Decide (Jonah Lehrer 2010). Pulled by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. [details]
Assassin of Secrets (Quentin Rowan 2011). Little, Brown and Company issued apology, recalled all books from online, brick-and-mortar stores, offered full refund to anyone who purchased book. [details]
The Raven’s Bride (Lenore Hart 2011). St Martin’s Press defends author. The best response to this defense is a Poe via the blog, The World of Edgar Allan Poe: “All I can do is offer some more words of wisdom from Mr. Poe himself: ‘To attempt the rebutting of a charge of plagiarism by the broad assertion that no such thing as plagiarism exists, is a sotticism, and no more.’ “ [Here’s the definition of sotticism.] Amazon still sells this book.
You’re Looking Well(Lewis Wolpert 2011). Faber and Faber stopped selling the book in 2014. Though it seems to be on Amazon. He plagiarized parts of his next book, it appears. [details]
Imagine (Jonah Lehrer 2012). Houghton Mifflin recalled all copies, reimbursed people if they wanted to bring in copy to where they bought it. [details]
Government Bullies (Rand Paul 2012). Center Street promised to fix the “misunderstanding.” [details]
A Call to Resurgence(Mark Driscoll 2013). InterVarsity Press seemed sorry, and explained how author erred, but I don’t think it recalled the book. [details]
Seeds of Hope (Jane Goodall with Gail Hudson 2013). Grand Central (Hachette) had author(s) rework the book for new publication. Hachette made public announcements about recall, reasons. [details]
Turnitin, the leading provider of plagiarism-detection software, is ubiquitous at the high school and college level. But I’ve always wondered if and when the service will be used in middle schools and, gasp, elementary schools. Well, Turnitin recently answered my query: middle schools are adopting it at “a fine clip,” but usage among elementary schools is rare. That latter, nonzero number is interesting — I would love to know how those elementary school teachers use it, potentially when some of their students cannot even read yet. As I’ve written elsewhere, elementary school is probably the best time to teach about authorship and honesty — it’s in those early grades that kids learn how to cut-and-paste, the plagiarizer’s favorite tool.
And for those districts that start using it with first graders, that means students will be exposed to plagiarism discussions for a good 12 years before they hit their first college course — that’s just amazing. If you’ve ever taught college students, you’ll know that when caught cheating, the top excuse is “but I didn’t know it was plagiarism … we never learned about that in high school.” With up to 12 (twelve!!) years of exposure, that certainly will be a lame excuse … though I’m sure they’ll still use it.
If anyone does research on the risk factors contributing to plagiarism among college students, it would be interesting to look at how their grade school teachers dealt with the plagiarism issue (ostriching, Turnitin, etc.). If you do it, please let me know …
One of the mildly entertaining things about having a blog is seeing what type of web searches lead people to my site. For me, key search terms usually include “killing camel crickets”. But “Dr Dorin Schumacher” is up there, too. The former is a pestiferous creature that dwells in dark places and leaves frass stains everywhere. The latter has a doctorate in French literature, has a fondness for wearing black, and heads a Georgia-based non-profit (The Consortium for Plant Biotechnology Research) that plagiarizes my site heavily. When I complained about the plagiarism, she used CPBR’s money (which comes from the DOE, USDA, and EPA … i.e., you) to hire a fancy lawyer to threaten me with copyright infringement. She has demanded that I take down my site or face hundreds of thousands of dollars in damages.
That was a year ago, and it seems like a fine day to make an anniversary post in her honor, if for no other reason than to solidify my awesome “Dr Dorin Schumacher” Google ranking.
When news of this frass behavior hit the internet last year, there was a lot of interest (albeit brief), even from people who don’t normally care about the design of scientific posters (the content of mine that CPBR had stolen and claimed was theirs). For example, the story crashed the servers at The Chronicle of Higher Education (that had never happened before, I was told). A lot of people contacted me with emails of sympathy, but nothing really affected Dr Schumacher’s little hive in St Simon’s Island (a resort town).
So here’s what I did: I spent a fun-filled week contacting Presidents, Grants Administration Chairs, and designated DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) Agents at every single one of CPBR’s member institutions. I informed them that CPBR’s document infringed on my copyrighted material, attached proof (PDFs, etc.), and asked them to stop emailing the document to their researchers. Naturally, forwarding material that is known to violate copyright is something universities traditionally avoid. I also informed the private corporations that they were trafficking a document that violated my copyright. Biotechnology corporations generally like copyright law, too.
One year later: not a single member has complied with my wishes — they are all still members of the CPBR racket (it diverts millions of dollars of taxpayer money that would normally go to USDA, EPA, and DOE grants). The only encouraging response I got was from a person who said, “we will continue to follow this” (yeah, thanks a lot). All of them apparently decided that ignoring my request (after all, just some snarky botanist in Swarthmore) would preserve the juicy financial benefits of continued CPBR membership.
And CPBR continues to email the document containing my text to all its member institutions and still has “copyright CPBR” plastered on the pages in question. In fact, everything seems to be peachy at CPBR in the resort town of St Simon’s Island, Georgia. They just finished an annual gathering in DC, and even had important government officials (Dr Johnathan Male, Department of Energy; Sanford Bishop, US House of Representatives) and scientists give keynote talks (see program details). And its funding seems rather secure (according to the DOE’s Dr Male in this PDF). The Department of Energy has given them $23 million dollars. Dr Schumacher pays herself $1/4 million per year.
So I thought it would be fun to list the member institutions below as a way to call attention to their inaction. If you’re an alum who might care to contact them, you’d get 17 karma points. If you want to contact the DOE office that gives CPBR its money, you can email them.
I created the PDF below because many students who post their talks on the internet seem to think it’s OK to plagiarize when using Powerpoint, Keynote, Prezi, etc. It’s just six slides because the average person will get bored after the first slide, when references to elevator romance abruptly stop. It ends on a few issues that have short answers, but you can add the details if you want. If you can help spread the word, great.